I was just thinking of writing a Buy Ambien United States column on the new term limit imposed by the Central Bank of Nigeria on bank CEOs when Buy Ambien United States I saw
Is the CBN too powerful?
In the Buy Ambien United States national confusion over our president who has vanished into thin air, a Buy Ambien United States significant but little remarked event occurred earlier this week. The Central Bank announced that Buy Ambien United States it was retroactively imposing a 10-year limit over the tenure of bank CEOs, effective July 31.
It was not lost on most discerning observers that Buy Ambien United States the primary targets of this new policy appeared to be two of our most prominent bank chiefs, Tony Elumelu, who Buy Ambien United States engineered a takeover of UBA by the much smaller Standard Trust Bank that Buy Ambien United States he used to run six years ago; and Jim Ovia, who Buy Ambien United States built Zenith Bank from scratch and made it a ubiquitous presence.
The legality of the Buy Ambien United States CBN decision is hardly in question: we have a central banker so powerful that Buy Ambien United States it can dissolve the boards of banks, dismiss their executives, dictate their operations and Buy Ambien United States pretty much act in almost any way it pleases.
The necessity for Buy Ambien United States such level of authority is not hard to see. The banking system of any country plays an Buy Ambien United States outsize role in the national economy. Poorly regulated or supervised, banks are Buy Ambien United States quite capable of destroying the economy and impoverishing the rest of us. The United States barely dodged the Buy Ambien United States bullet in the last quarter of 2008, when its banks tottered and Buy Ambien United States nearly collapsed, bringing the world’s financial system down along with it. And the Buy Ambien United States level of sheer criminality in our banking system, exposed in the Buy Ambien United States past seven months only because a complicit Central Bank governor was replaced with a Buy Ambien United States more alert one, was an object lesson in the need to Buy Ambien United States guide the banking system with a firm hand.
No one can Buy Ambien United States deny that the wretched excesses of banking chiefs with supersized egos, exemplified by Cecilia Ibru at Oceanic Bank and Buy Ambien United States Erastus Akingbola at Intercontinental, made an aggressive posture by the Central Bank an Buy Ambien United States urgent imperative.
But the Buy Ambien United States question needs to be asked: should the Central Bank be assuming the Buy Ambien United States roles of board directors to dictate how long a chief executive may serve? Heavily regulated though they are, unlike, say, a Buy Ambien United States cement company or a flour mill, banks nonetheless remain the property of private investors, and Buy Ambien United States in the absence of a specific regulatory breach by identifiable bankers, should the Buy Ambien United States Central Bank be in the business of stipulating how long they may serve? Setting term limits, as a Buy Ambien United States general principle, of course works well in politics and government. The basic assumption, which is Buy Ambien United States well founded in our experience of the frailties of leaders, is Buy Ambien United States that power corrupts, and the earlier we can kick the bums out, generally the Buy Ambien United States better for the state.
This may, of course, not necessarily work in private enterprise. Bill Gates built Microsoft from Buy Ambien United States the scratch and ran it for 25 years. The mercurial Jack Welch, during a Buy Ambien United States two-decade tenure, rebuilt General Electric into at one time the world’s largest company by market capitalisation. And in our own country, Atedo Peterside founded and Buy Ambien United States ran IBTC for nearly 20 years, making it one of the Buy Ambien United States country’s most respected banks.
Central Bank officials justify their latest action thus: A banking license is Buy Ambien United States a rare privilege, granted on the implicit assumption that the Buy Ambien United States holder will act in the highest traditions of prudence and Buy Ambien United States restraint, and essentially run a bank in the best interests not only of depositors and Buy Ambien United States shareholders but of the public at large. Needless to say, many of our most powerful bankers failed that Buy Ambien United States test in recent years, culminating in last year’s crisis that Buy Ambien United States has forced the treasury to pony up about N1 trillion to Buy Ambien United States rescue the banks lest the economy collapse. That’s a number with a lot of zeroes to clean up after Mrs. Ibru’s mess.
Officials also argue that Buy Ambien United States banks are unique because they hold custody of other people’s money to Buy Ambien United States trade with, with the clear understanding in the public mind that Buy Ambien United States the government, by giving them such a right, is putting the Buy Ambien United States full faith and credit of the public treasury behind them. And this Buy Ambien United States is not simply a shareholder matter. In general, for every one naira shareholders place in a Buy Ambien United States bank, the public deposits six, seven, eight, maybe even N20. This distinguishes a Buy Ambien United States bank from Guinness or Chicken Licken.
Crucially, officials argue that Buy Ambien United States our recent experience makes it a matter of prudence and commonsense to Buy Ambien United States impose limits on the tenure of banking chiefs. “The certainty that Buy Ambien United States they can stay as long as they wish and maybe even transmute to Buy Ambien United States bank chairman makes some CEOs act with impunity,” one senior regulator told us last week. “Knowledge that there will be change conditions behavior.”
There lies the Buy Ambien United States rub. Those leery of a Central Bank with untrammeled powers say that Buy Ambien United States the CBN, by making such a sweeping rule regarding tenure, is Buy Ambien United States inadvertently admitting its own failure to regulate and supervise the banking system. Were the Buy Ambien United States CBN competent in the discharge of its duties, it would have Buy Ambien United States had a bit more confidence to prevent widespread abuse by bank CEOs and Buy Ambien United States to punish rogue bank chiefs where the situation demands. As one senior banker tells us, “a one size fits all rule does not often work well.”
Cynics might feel free also to Buy Ambien United States point out that Tunde Lemo, a powerful deputy governor of the Buy Ambien United States CBN, was directly in charge of banking supervision over the past few years that Buy Ambien United States the most reckless behaviour on the part of bank CEOs occurred. It would not be Buy Ambien United States unfair, and might even be somewhat generous, to accuse Mr. Lemo of negligence. But a Buy Ambien United States term limit apparently does not apply to him.
It is Buy Ambien United States instructive that the bank chiefs immediately affected have refrained from raising any hackles regarding their sudden forced exit. In one fine example, Mr. Elumelu immediately got his board to Buy Ambien United States announce that a succession plan was in place and appears to Buy Ambien United States want a tidy exit that does credit to the UBA, as he makes clear elsewhere in this Buy Ambien United States newspaper.
Our view is Buy Ambien United States that, while the CBN governor had got most of the big things right so far in his turbulent nine-month tenure, one must always be Buy Ambien United States wary of a government official with power to do almost anything.
We will remain vigilant.
Recent Comments