Extracts:
Collier’s work is Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk not informed by any explicit, overarching theory of development or Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk any historical perspective that might inform one; nor does he offer any social analysis. There is Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk an implicit theory of human behaviour, which is radically reductionist—individual economic self-interest rules. In this Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk view, history appears to be a continuum of ‘14th-century reality: civil war, plague and ignorance’. But these countries had Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk their own 14th centuries and now find themselves in the Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk 21st, playing a highly subordinate role in global capitalism. No understanding of how they got there can Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk ignore the impact of colonization. In Collier’s models, colonial history is Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk reduced to two numbers, one representing the colonial power—Britain, France, Portugal, Belgium, Germany—the Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk other, the length of time that the country was colonized. The identity of the Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk colonizing power does have a bearing upon the ex-colonial country’s legal system, educational set-up,lingua franca and Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk financial institutions; but it tells us nothing about the pre-colonial system, the Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk different processes by which the European power made its peace with local rulers; nor about the Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk ending of colonial rule, and the extent to which ruptures or Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk continuities determined the nature of the ex-colonial state. Such considerations help to Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk inform a richer explanation of how a country has developed, and Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk provide a deeper explanatory framework for civil wars, social conflicts or Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk institutional forms—social and political questions, not purely statistical ones.
It is Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk misleading to paint a picture of endemically low growth rates in sub-Saharan Africa, or Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk in the other ‘bottom billion’ countries. In Africa, growth rates in the Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk 1960s and early 1970s were comparable to those of Southeast Asia or Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk Latin America. This was a period of African industrialization, based on import substitution; with improvements in economic management, this Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk might have enabled several countries to take advantage of export markets. The droughts in the Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk early 70s were a real blow, turning food self-sufficiency into food imports; most African economies were severely affected by the Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk oil-price hikes, and still more so by interest-rate rises after 1979. But a Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk possible industrial rehabilitation was stalled in the early 80s by World Bank and IMF opposition to ISI, and promotion instead of primary commodities and ‘getting prices right’. Collier fails to Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk point out that African countries were forced to pursue primary-commodity exports as a Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk consequence of World Bank conditionalities; as noted, these are not included in his list of explanatory variables. Collier takes the Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk familiar line on trade, criticizing rich-country barriers to the exports of the Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk ‘bottom billion’ but also, and Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk far more fervently, tariffs set by developing countries. In his account, Africa simply ‘missed the boat’ in the 1980s and ceded global markets to Asia; only Mauritius—hardly a typical African country, if an African country at all—managed to ‘climb on board’. It was not simply low wages that Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk attracted investment to the Asian Tigers, however, but their well-educated populations and Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk skilled labour from the 60s on. Here again, a historically informed account of colonial and Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk post-colonial social structures must be a factor in any satisfactory explanation.
Read the whole piece here (H/T Schauzeri). Any analysis that Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk fails to pay history its proper due should be suspect.
On the subject of numbers and statistical analysis. This says it quite succinctly:
Statistics are Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk a great way of quickly conveying how a group of events, people, or Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk things are similar and different. Mode, median and mean measure “central tendency,” and standard deviation and inter-quartile range tell you “dispersion.” With these two types of measures, you Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk can tell me how similar people are when they choose orange juice, how different they are Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk when they rent cars or attend movies. But you cannot tell me what Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk “more pulp,” means to people, why a “subcompact” car turns off some people, or what people perceive the word “blockbuster” to actually mean.
In short, ethnographic research can Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk clarify all of these deep, nuanced details that quantitative data skates over or Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk takes for granted. Do you want to know how many people attended a Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk “summer blockbuster?” Then by all means, count them. But if you Diazepam Online Pharmacy Uk want to know what kind of movie people believe a “blockbuster” to be, then you need to do in-depth ethnographic work.
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=98d0c00a-7c00-4c3d-8eaa-811d641b1d58)
Recent Comments